Nina's Five Star Pizza

Discover Nina's Five Star Pizza in Scranton, PA, offering delicious NY-style pizza, cheesy subs, and more at great prices. Call +1 570-344-2255 for your favorite pie today!

Welcome to Nina's Five Star Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza

Nina's Five Star Pizza stands out as a beloved gem on Pittston Avenue, right in the heart of Scranton. Known for its unmistakable New York-style pizza, the establishment attracts locals and visitors alike with its family-friendly atmosphere and mouthwatering menu. The vibrant scent of freshly baked pizza fills the air as you step inside, instantly igniting your appetite. Pricing is approachable, making it a perfect spot for lunch, dinner, or a quick takeaway.

You can indulge in a classic slice or try unique specialties like heart-shaped Neapolitan pizzas and sweet apple tiramisu. Expect a warm welcome when you arrive, as the lively staff is dedicated to making your pizza experience unforgettable.

Location & Contact

Address

1429 Pittston Ave, Scranton, PA 18505, United States

Phone

+1 570-344-2255

About

Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza
Nina's Five Star Pizza

Nina's Five Star Pizza captures the spirit of Scranton, blending tradition with a contemporary dining experience. This pizzeria has established itself as a community hub, where people gather for good food and conversation. The kitchen prides itself on crafting each pizza to perfection using quality ingredients, celebrating the age-old art of pizza making while emphasizing local flavors. The New York-style pizzas are particularly popular among locals, who appreciate the generous portions and authentic taste.

The appeal of Nina's stretches beyond pizzas, with many customers raving about their subs and cheese steaks, each made with care and precision.

The restaurant has embraced its identity as a family-friendly joint, welcoming everyone from busy professionals grabbing lunch to families enjoying a leisurely dinner. Monday's peak dining time creates an electric atmosphere, drawing in pizza lovers eager to enjoy a slice of the good life.

Amid the bustling sounds of joyful chatter and the sizzling of pizzas in the oven, one can truly feel the heartbeat of the community.

What makes Nina's special is not just the food; it's about the experience. Regular patrons often mention the staff's attentiveness and the genuine friendliness that makes every visit enjoyable. With a commitment to quality and a focus on customer satisfaction, Nina's Five Star Pizza has become a key player in Scranton’s gastronomic scene, combining delicious dishes with an unpretentious atmosphere that feels like home. Every meal served here tells a story of community, connection, and of course, great pizza.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-10 PM
  • Monday11 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Nina's Five Star Pizza boasts several enticing features that keep guests returning for more. First, the diverse menu offers something for everyone, from classic cheese and pepperoni pizzas to hearty cheese steaks and fresh subs. Diners can also savor decadent desserts, including a delightful tiramisu. Peak dining hours tend to see a full restaurant, especially on Mondays at 11 AM when popularity hits its highest capacity.

Therefore, planning your visit during off-peak times may ensure a more relaxed dining experience. The casual ambiance provides ample seating, perfect for families or larger groups looking to unwind and enjoy a good meal. Delivery and takeout options also make it convenient for those on the go, ensuring that great pizza is just a phone call away.

Nina's Five Star Pizza

Nina's Five Star Pizza presents a welcoming exterior that invites passersby to come inside. The classic signage highlights the pizzeria's name, and ample parking makes access easy for those driving in. The outdoor area typically buzzes with activity during warmer months, where friends gather around tables, enjoying their pizza and the pleasant Scranton weather. The vibrant atmosphere evokes a sense of community spirit, encouraging both newcomers and regulars to join in the fun at Nina’s.

Customer Reviews

What an amazing place! I'm not from the area as I'm an over the road truck driver in town cause my truck broke down and man the pizza is incredible! The cheese fries are perfect and the owner himself delivered my food! Every bit of my experience has been amazing and I cant recommend them enough!

N
Nicolae M.

Pizza was delicious! Wanted crumbled hot sausage. Joe only had pieces of hot sausage. So he crumbled up a raw piece of sausage. Cooked it and put it on the pizza. Thanks Joe.

T
Tommy

Best pizza around so far taste close to New Jersey pizza and there pasta salad is really good

H
Hailey P.

Honestly the best New York -style pizza in the area! The cheese steak sub my friend ordered to-go was an ACTUAL cheese steak... Loaded with meat and cheese; unlike the "bread subs" (as I call them, skimpy on meat) you'd get elsewhere!!!! There's a spacious indoor dining area along with a cute outdoor seating area in front. The restroom is squeaky clean, with warm water, soap and paper towels (very important)! The owners are super friendly and make you feel right at home, too. So, do yourself a favour and stop by! Tell your friends! I know we'll be back!

L
Lee K.

Best pizza I ever had. They custom make any kind of pizza you can think of any kind of way. And the people that work there are so kind. They make you feel like you're the most important customer there is. I love this place. I would give it more than five stars if I could.

M
Matt P.

Great thin crust pizza! Lots of options, pizza is hot fresh and quick out the oven.

S
Stephen M.